Kristof Found Them in South Sudan: The Deportees Trump 'Disappeared' — Locked Up and Famished
A New York Times columnist went looking for men the Trump administration deported to countries they have no connection with — and he says he found them.
Nicholas Kristof, reporting from Juba, the capital of South Sudan, says he tracked down five of the deported men in a house where they are being held prisoner — locked up and, in his words, famished. The account, published this week, has turned one of the administration's most controversial immigration policies into a human story with names, faces and a location on the map.
For months, the deportations to third countries have been debated in courtrooms and on Capitol Hill. Now, for the first time, a reporter says he has found the men at the centre of it.
A guarded compound in Juba, South Sudan — where, according to Nicholas Kristof's reporting, five deportees are being held.
Five Men in a House in Juba
According to Kristof's reporting, the five men he found in Juba include two Cubans and two men from Myanmar. None of them has any connection to South Sudan — a country thousands of miles from home, riven by conflict and poverty.
Kristof describes the men as held prisoner in a house, locked up and short of food. One man told him he was locked in his room for asking for clean water. The details are stark: men who were deported from the United States now confined in a foreign country they did not choose, with little idea of what happens next.
The columnist's account does not claim to have located every deportee sent to African countries — only these five. But their story has given the policy a face, and the images from Juba have spread quickly across social media.
500+ Sent to Countries They Don't Know
The five men in Juba are part of a much larger pattern, according to Kristof's reporting. Since taking office, the administration has deported more than 500 immigrants to African countries — often, the reporting says, by pressing weak governments to accept people who have no ties there.
Third-country deportations — sending someone not to their home country but to a third nation willing to take them — have become one of the administration's signature immigration tools. Supporters say it is a way to remove people whose home countries refuse to take them back. Critics say it strands people in places where they have no family, no language and no legal status.
South Sudan is among the most striking destinations. The country, the world's youngest nation, has been plagued by civil conflict, and the US State Department itself warns Americans against travel there. For the deportees, it is not a fresh start — it is, by Kristof's account, a locked room.
What the Administration Says
The administration's position, as reported, is that the men had final orders of removal and criminal convictions — and that the deportations are lawful. Officials have argued that third-country removals are necessary when home countries will not cooperate, and that the courts have allowed the practice to continue while legal challenges play out.
That defence is now facing its biggest test. The Supreme Court has fast-tracked December hearings on whether third-country deportations are constitutional — a case that could decide the fate not only of the men in Juba but of hundreds of others sent to countries across Africa and beyond.
Kristof's reporting does not settle the legal question. What it does is put human detail behind a policy that, until now, has mostly been argued in abstractions: a house in Juba, five locked rooms, and men asking for clean water.
The US immigration court system — the Supreme Court will hear arguments in December on whether third-country deportations are constitutional.
What to Watch
All eyes now turn to the Supreme Court's December hearings. The justices will decide whether the administration can keep sending people to countries they have no connection with — or whether the practice must stop. A ruling either way would reshape American immigration enforcement for years.
Watch, too, for the administration's response to Kristof's reporting: whether officials confirm the men's whereabouts, whether they offer any account of their conditions, and whether more reporters or lawyers are able to reach the deportees in Juba. And watch South Sudan itself — whether the government there continues to accept deportees, and under what terms.
🗽 The Bottom Line
A columnist went to Juba looking for men the system had, in effect, disappeared — and he found them, locked up and hungry, thousands of miles from home. The Supreme Court will decide in December whether the policy that put them there is constitutional. Until then, the five men in that house in Juba are the human face of one of America's most contested immigration fights.


Comments
Post a Comment